What do Hillary Clinton, Sonia Sotomayor, Elizabeth Warren and Kamala Harris have in common? They each were on their high school debate teams. Over the past few years something insidious has snuck into politics, and it has everything to do with the skills these women worked so hard to develop as teenagers.
Against Goliath is a tale of girls finding their voices, and raises crucial questions about gender (race and class) bias in America today. Like national politics, high school debate is male dominated — more males than females debate, reach finals, and win. Shot over four years, the film follows the Newton South High School Public Forum Debate team as they learn to become better debaters and confront bias head on. In this intensely competitive, demanding extracurricular activity, the novices, as well as the rest of the team, develop and refine their speaking and research skills, build their confidence, and debate in regional and national tournaments, while struggling with how to present themselves in a world dominated by boys. Most of the debaters are first generation Americans, with native languages like Russian, Hebrew, Spanish, Vietnamese, Mandarin, Hindi, Urdu or Ukrainian, who will likely become the country's next leaders — doctors, lawyers, engineers, teachers and politicians.
In a charged political climate when leaders are trained to alter appearance and personality to succeed, it is crucial that we question expectations and teach the importance of respectfully speaking up. Debate offers a model for understanding complexities of political issues and the value of fact based research. Debate is also a cautionary tale — that winning is not always based on the logic of an argument. As these high school girl debaters remain determined to win despite the odds, they can inspire future leaders, both boys and girls, that equal rights and freedom of expression are worth fighting for, both within debate and beyond.
view how you can Help with the production of this film by visiting our donate page
Barbash and Small first met at the Flaherty Seminar in 2008 when Lisa was completing post-production on SWEETGRASS (co-created with Lucien Castaing Taylor) and Lucia was distributing THE AXE IN THE ATTIC (co-created with Ed Pincus). Despite their different approaches to filmmaking, Small and Barbash connected artistically and began supporting each others' endeavors until 2015 when they teamed up to work on Against Goliath (formerly titled The Debate Film). From 2015 to 2017, Anna Graham was an integral part of the team, as Sound Recordist and Editing Assistant. Recently, Rebecca Williams joined the team as Sound Recordist and Assistant Editor to assist Lucia with the film through its completion.
Anna Graham - Sound Recordist, Assistant Editor